|Mess Hall Online Sportsbook Discussion|
| ||LinkBack||Thread Tools|
ARTICLE...TORONTO BLUE JAYS: Whitest team in the majors
Jun. 28, 2003. 01:17 PM
Venturing into the Blue Jays clubhouse less than two years ago meant having your ears filled with the buzz of Spanish dialects from Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, Mexico and South America.
A glance around the room would take in not only the Latin American players chatting among themselves, but also a good number of blacks from the United States dressing alongside their white counterparts. Such a scene was nothing new. A Jays team once led by Joe Carter, Robbie Alomar, George Bell, Tony Fernandez and Devon White was for years known to be as diverse as the city it represents. That is no longer the case.
A study by the Star has found that this year's edition of the Blue Jays had the fewest number of visible minorities on the opening-day roster of any of the 30 major-league teams. A Toronto club that boasted of its diversity in recent radio ads actually had the visible-minority players on its 25-man roster drop from 11 on opening day a year ago to only six this season.
Fuelling that change has been a rapid decline in the number of Latin Americans suiting up for Toronto, a drop that comes even as their numbers expand throughout baseball. The Jays in their glory years were a haven for players of Latin American descent, but the three they had on opening day — and the four they now have — were the fewest of any team.
Opening-day rosters, not current ones, were used for the study for easier comparisons between teams and years.
Despite being the most homogeneous squad in baseball, the important fact remains that the Jays are winning and contending for a playoff spot. Toronto was only three games out of first place in the American League East yesterday as it entered a weekend series with the Montreal Expos, who, coincidentally, began the season with the most visible-minority players.
That raises the issue of whether the Jays truly need to be more representative of the city they play in at a time when they are satisfying fans by winning. A less obvious issue, one bound to generate heated debate, is whether Toronto has somehow gained an advantage by bucking baseball's diversity trend — and whether others will copy this model and change the demographics of the game.
"I believe the vast majority of people will come to see a winning ball club, whether it has nine Dominicans, nine Americans or nine people from Japan on the field," Jays president and CEO Paul Godfrey said. "I think the excitement generated by a winning team far outweighs any other consideration."
Godfrey also doesn't believe the victorious Jays are setting any kind of trend for teams to emulate. He believes that even to concede there is a trend here would suggest the Jays have targeted white players as a priority, an insinuation he rejects.
"Baseball teams don't sit down and say, `I'll take so many of those and so many of those,'" he said, adding he wasn't aware of Toronto's low visible-minority ranking until now. "I don't believe in quotas on or off the field. I want the best person in the position, on or off the field."
Peter Donnelly, director of the Centre for Sports Policy Studies at the University of Toronto, was stunned to hear that the Jays, once hailed for diversity, now have so few minorities relative to the rest of baseball.
"You're talking about the most multicultural city in the world," Donnelly said. "In many ways, Toronto is more multicultural than New York. So, there's a responsibility there and it probably makes marketing sense to reflect your community.
"You go to a Jays game when Seattle's in town and look at the number of Japanese fans in the stands," he said in reference to the Mariners' Ichiro Suzuki.
Complicating the entire issue of race is the fact the Jays aren't really seeking the best players available, many of whom happen to be non-white. Budget-conscious Toronto instead is looking for value.
And the facts show the Jays took a dramatic, economically beneficial turn toward a much whiter roster after J.P. Ricciardi was named general manager in November 2001. Of the 39 players Ricciardi has since acquired through trades, free agency or waiver claims, 36 of them — 92 per cent — are white.
Those moves have seriously altered the makeup of the Jays, who had 11 visible-minority players on the opening-day roster the past three seasons and at least 10 each year since 1994.
Ricciardi is at a loss to explain the numbers as anything beyond coincidence, although he does correctly point out that the number of black players in the game has steadily declined. The number of Latin Americans, on the other hand, has more than doubled since 1991 and they made up 28 per cent of the 750 players on opening-day rosters. Also, 54.4 per cent of the players were white and 45.6 per cent were either Latin American, black, Asian or Native American.
"We don't look at players as black and white," Ricciardi said, adding that his job was to put together the best possible team within the budget. "We do look at players for what they can do for us."
Ricciardi, who has a Cuban-born manager in Carlos Tosca, doubts fans care much about a team's racial makeup. He cited the Expos, who began the season tied with the Texas Rangers at 14 visible-minority players, including12 Latin Americans, one black and one Asian, as an example.
"Look at the Expos and all the players they have and they still get only 5,000 people coming to their games," Ricciardi said.
Of the 21 free agents signed by Ricciardi, the only non-whites have been since-departed outfielder Pedro Swann and recent bullpen pick-up Juan Acevedo. Toronto's only non-white of 13 players acquired in trades was relief pitcher Felix Heredia, no longer with the team. All five of Ricciardi's waiver claims were white players.
Two of the four players Ricciardi kept from the Rule 5 draft, in which teams choose unprotected minor-league prospects from other organizations, have been non-whites Aquilino Lopez and Corey Thurman. Even including their names among Ricciardi's acquisitions still means nine out of every 10 new players coming to Toronto are white. Despite that, no one is complaining too loudly about Ricciardi's moves.
That's because many of the white players Ricciardi imported, such as Eric Hinske, Frank Catalanotto, Greg Myers, Tom Wilson and Mike Bordick, are resounding successes. Their performances have complemented the play of Toronto's two biggest offensive stars, Puerto Rico native Carlos Delgado and black Texan Vernon Wells, who have helped the Jays soar into contention.
Ricciardi has purged the team of higher-priced talent and replaced it largely with imported players in their late 20s and early 30s who have yet to attain free-agent service time. That nearly all of those new players are white will be less interesting to some GMs than their average salary of only $642,000 (U.S.) compared to the $2.5 million being paid the average non-white who left the team.
Just as difficult to overlook will be the Toronto clubhouse, described by Jays players and management as the most harmonious and clique-free they've seen. It wouldn't be a stretch for some GMs to assume that a clubhouse with fewer language divisions and cultural differences makes for more harmony.
Ricciardi won't make that assumption, saying his players merely accept their differences.
"We have guys who all get along," Ricciardi said. "I think it's only an issue if you make it an issue. To go into a clubhouse and see Carlos Delgado, (Eric) Hinske and Frank Catalanotto talking baseball ... I don't think they care.
"I'd like to think we're beyond that at this stage in the world."
But Donnelly said having a team more in line with baseball norms regarding minorities should be important to a team struggling to sell tickets.
"I would say that it's crucial in Toronto," he said. "They can't be happy that they're only playing in front of crowds of 18,000 to 20,000. Winning is important, but there may be more than one way to skin a cat in the world's most multicultural city. And short of winning a World Series, they're not getting the attention other teams in the city get."
While players come and go throughout a season, the racial makeup of most teams remains surprisingly consistent. The Jays temporarily upped their visible-minority total to seven by adding Mexican-born Acevedo two weeks ago, but the number could go right back down again with possible upcoming trades involving black outfielder Shannon Stewart and Venezuelan pitcher Kelvim Escobar.
The most valuable commodity I know of is information
This gets my vote as the stupidest baseball article of the year.
Belabor the points of color and nationality, but skip right over the fact that the skipper is from Cuba.
Funny thing, as the Jays were knocking at the first place door this week, I found myself not knowing who the manager even was. So I looked it up and the name not being familiar to me, I just forgot to look into his history further. Now I wish I had so I could comment more on this nonissue.
"But Donnelly said having a team more in line with baseball norms regarding minorities should be important to a team struggling to sell tickets."
So he's saying the bluejays have too many whiteboys on the team and are not culturally diverse enough, GIMME-A-BREAK!
Hmm, no mention about the wonderful diversity of the Toronto Raptors in this article either. I guess none of those dozens of non black players who pounded the handed picked USA team in those world games last year could help the Raptors huh..
And this from a paper that rails against the publication of racially denominated crime statistics. So I guess it's ok to point out race in baseball but not in crime?
a complete and utter embarrasement. The reporter should be fired on the spot. Almost as bad as what the Miami paper did to Jose Santos.
Jays livid about 'White Jays' article
TORONTO (CP) - The Toronto Blue Jays reacted angrily Saturday to a newspaper article they felt insinuated the organization is racist. The front-page story in Saturday's Toronto Star, with the headline ``Whitest Team in the Majors,'' said the Blue Jays had the fewest number of visible minorities on the opening-day roster of any of the 30 big-league clubs. ``It was probably the stupidest thing I've ever seen,'' said first baseman Carlos Delgado, who is both black and Latin. ``When you come up with something as stupid as that, we're going to decide to forget it and pretend nothing happened. ``It's just embarrassing for their paper. We've done a lot of good things, and sometimes we get half-a-page. They used the front page of their paper, they got a full page in the sports section, it's just ridiculous.'' The story pointed out that last season the Jays had 11 visible minorities on opening day, compared to six this season, with a decline in the number of Latin Americans suiting up for the team to blame. ``We've got a great team, who cares if we're white or black or Latin?'' said Delgado. ``That should never, ever be an issue. I don't see anyone saying you don't have any black players in hockey - same city. ``So what's the difference?'' The article also pointed out that the Blue Jays, with four, have the fewest Latin American players of any team. ``We don't have Latin players, black players, green players on our squad, we have Blue Jay players,'' said general manager J.P. Ricciardi. ``We don't look at them in any way, shape or form as far as what their colour, race or religion is. We look at them as, can they help us? ``I didn't think it was a very fair article.'' The Montreal Expos began the season with the most visible-minority players, according to the article. Both Expos manager Frank Robinson and Blue Jays skip Carlos Tosca, who is Cuban, declined comment. ``It's not even worth mentioning,'' said Tosca.
This gets my vote as the stupidest baseball article of the year.
Right GF- make that DECADE !
Just for fun, I though that article so idiotic, that I grabbed my trusty Media Guide for the 1992/1993 Championship years:
Here's the Starting Lineup the day they beat Atlanta:
And in 1993, the night Carter beat the Wild Thing:
The Blue Jays, along with the LA Dodgers, were the 2 teams to start the Dominican pipeline into the Majors!
This article is so stupid that it doesn't realize that exactly the opposite of their suggested slant has happened. The $uper $tar every day players are predominantly BLACK/ DOMINICAN/ PUERTO RICAN- persons of colour. But the Js with their $53 mill payroll can't afford them anymore !
So Ricciardi scoops up the cheap, hard nosed white guys to keep them competitive. Who wouldn't want a team populated with Bernie Williams, Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa, etc. ?
But the Js can't afford them, you MORON !
As Delgado himself pointed out:
I don't see anyone saying you don't have any black players in hockey - same city. ``So what's the difference?''
Exactly, Carlos !
" A life is not important, except in the impact it has on other lives. " JRR